The Psychology of Customer Acquisition - Why it's so difficult and what you can do about that!

Every single company must contend with the challenges of new-customer acquisition. Whether you are Amazon, or the corner deli, new customer acquisition is critical to business, both new and mature, due to organic turnover and the need for growth.

While many companies strategize the growth aspect of their new customer acquisition, far fewer of them facilitate the replacement of lost business, believing somehow that they are immune from the effects of organic turnover.

In considering the challenges of new-customer acquisition, there are myriad factors that impede success. Some of the most resonant challenges can be found in the annals of psychology, others are a little esoteric. I’ll start with the most blindingly obvious (and, unfortunately, ‘blindingly’ is often the operative word).   

 1) You Suck

No company or brand has a divine right to exist. If your brand is not a quality product, and you’re trying to play in a premium space, you don’t matter. If your pricing is not right for the market you are looking to compete in, you don’t matter. If your delivery does not align with baseline expectations, you don’t matter.

If you have friction throughout your operation - marketing sales, training, etc. - you don’t matter. If you don’t have a good story to tell, or can’t tell it, you don’t matter. If you don’t have the requisite team to tell your story because you’ve hired the wrong people, or because you won’t or can’t hire the right salespeople, you don’t matter.

Those are some of the factors that you control, or don’t, as the case may be. Now let’s explore some of the psychological reasons that your target customers may not be responding to you as quickly as you’d like, or not at all.

2) Inertia

Assuming you are none of the above, a major hurdle is just pure unadulterated inertia. Our brain has been described as a lazy piece of meat, and it doesn’t want to do anything it doesn’t have to do. It will default to “no,” not because you don’t have a great product, price, or story, but because thinking is hard for most people (cognitively expensive) and the least amount of it they have to do, the better it is for them.

Evolutionarily, our brain wants to tend to matters of food, survival, and pro-creation, and much as you may love what you bring to the table, and perhaps even believe it would be great for my business, for me, it’s a distraction when automatic pilot is a far more attractive state.

3) Status Quo Bias

Status Quo bias is related to inertia. I may not love my current supplier, I may wish the service was better, that the margins were better, that I liked the salesman more, but gosh, just thinking about the cost of switching in time, money, and energy (there’s that cognitive overload again), is too much to contemplate.

My current situation may not be ideal, but it is the beast I know, and that, right or wrong, has a certain comfort to it.  

4) Regret Avoidance

What if I switch and don’t like the new option any better? I’ll have deconstructed my old relationships and the infrastructure around what I was doing based on the possibility that the new brand will be an improvement. What if it doesn’t perform better? What if my people hate it and yearn for the old brand, warts and all?

The anticipation of regret is a powerful antidote to change. In many respects, psychological research has shown that the promise of what’s new must be at least twice as appealing to warrant comparison to the option I already own, however imperfect.

5) Sunk Cost Fallacy

I’ve spent so much money on this brand. I own a ton of inventory. I’ve invested in marketing for years. I’ve spent time and money on training. My people are used to it.

Sunk costs can be rationalized yet still present a strong emotive deterrent to change. Besides, what about all those customers I’ve previously sold? If I switch to another brand, what would it say to them about what I was selling them previously?

 

What Should You Do…


Don’t Suck

It is very difficult to be objective about your own business. So much so that close to one-hundred-percent of brands think companies ought to want to do business with them. This self-delusion provides terrific cover for all manner of shortcomings.  

In a world of nuance and greys, this much is certain; don’t suck. Whether you operate in the premium space, or in an off-price arena, you’ve got to have your shit together.

Don’t make excuses for your shortcomings. Fix them. If you can’t, or choose not to fix them, see the above note about no business having a right to exist.

Curated Story

Potential customers will not expend the mental bandwidth to consider all of the gradations and machinations of what you think is important about your brand. Telling them more reasons to buy from you is a liability, not a benefit.

Curate your story in a way that can be easily communicated and readily understood and point out the downside of playing it safe and not buying your brand.

 Narrow and Deep

Start with the things that are most resonant about your offering. You can always expand into related products once you have traction, but the more you try to communicate, the less easily it will be understood.

The Wizard of Oz did not start with a detailed explanation of how to build sparkly red shoes, and nor should your brand.

 Consistently Showing Up

The psychology known as the ‘mere exposure effect’ suggests that the more we see a message, the more we are likely to be impressed by it. Few offers, no matter how exciting, will move someone to bite on first viewing.

You’ve got to show up and tell your story again and again to benefit from the psychology of repeated exposure. New customer acquisition is a long game, no matter how short your patience.

 Build A Relationship

Showing up a lot shouldn’t be overtly self-serving and doesn’t have to repeat the same pattern.

You can benefit from the mere exposure effect with occasional informal touches, trade-show exposure, and, of course, more formal visits to the business.

The central theme is to build a relationship, aided by familiarity and warmth, not to pound your target into submission.

Summary

In summary, get your house in order first, then curate your message around the most important things you do. Hire the right sales team and have them tell that story by showing up again and again at the appropriate target customers. And lastly, recognize that new-customer acquisition is neither easy, nor a nice-to-have, it is mission critical.


Peter Smith is a consultant, executive coach and sales training expert. He is a keynote and breakout speaker who teaches leadership, hiring, and sales psychology. He is the author of three books, Hiring Squirrels, Sell Something, and The Sales Minute.

He can be reached at TheRetailSmiths@gmail.com  on LinkedIn, and TheRetailSmiths.com