The Retail Smiths: Is It Time to Rethink Men’s Jewelry?

Canton, MA--A few years ago, if someone had told me we'd be talking about men’s brooches in the jewelry industry, I probably would have laughed. Today, I think independent jewelers should be paying attention.

For years, when most of us thought about men's jewelry, we thought about wedding bands first. Maybe a watch. If a customer was a little more fashion-forward, perhaps a gold chain, bracelet or even cuff links.

That’s changing.

Men’s jewelry has become one of the fastest-growing segments of the jewelry industry, and I don't believe it's just another passing trend. According to Polaris Market Research, the global men's jewelry market is expected to grow at nearly 10% annually over the next decade, outpacing the growth of the overall jewelry market.¹ When one segment is growing faster than the industry as a whole, I think it's worth asking whether we’re giving it the attention it deserves.

So, what’s driving it?

I think it’s a combination of factors.

Professional athletes have certainly played a role in bringing men’s jewelry into the mainstream. Turn on an NBA game, watch the NFL arrivals before kickoff, or spend five minutes watching Formula 1, and you'll see necklaces, bracelets, rings, earrings, and luxury watches worn as naturally as a tailored suit. Athletes like LeBron James and Lewis Hamilton haven't just embraced jewelry, they've made it part of their signature look.

Brands like Cartier, Tiffany & Co., Louis Vuitton, Boucheron, and Hermès are showcasing men’s jewelry in ways we rarely saw a decade ago. The emphasis isn't on whether a piece is designed for a man or a woman. It's about craftsmanship, individuality, and personal style. The Financial Times recently highlighted how luxury houses are increasingly blurring traditional gender lines in jewelry as consumer preferences continue to evolve. ²

Perhaps the trend that has surprised me the most is the return of the brooch.

Yes...the brooch.

Once considered something reserved for women’s fashion or your grandmother’s jewelry box, it has found its way onto the lapels of some of today's best-dressed men. Timothée Chalamet, Colman Domingo, Barry Keoghan, Adrien Brody and other celebrities have worn brooches on tuxedos and sport coats at major awards shows, helping reintroduce the accessory to a new generation. Sotheby’s has also reported growing interest in brooches among male collectors, noting that men now account for roughly 20 to 25 percent of brooch buyers.³

I have to admit; this trend has even made its way into my own home.

If you happen to see Peter and me at a trade show, ask him about his squirrel brooch—a signed Hermès piece I surprised him with for his birthday. It almost always starts a conversation, which is exactly what great jewelry should do.

Now, before anyone thinks I'm suggesting you rush out and stock a showcase full of brooches, that's not my point.

The bigger opportunity isn't the brooch itself. It's recognizing that men's jewelry has expanded far beyond what many of us have traditionally carried.

Today's customer may be interested in a substantial gold chain, a beautifully crafted signet ring, a bold bracelet, diamond or gemstone studs, or yes, even a brooch worn on a sport coat or dinner jacket. Will every man wear these pieces? Of course not. But more men are asking about them than they were even five years ago.

I also think we sometimes overlook another important customer.

Women

Maybe she’s already bought him the watch. The wallet. The golf clubs. Finding something that's both personal and unexpected isn't always easy. A distinctive piece of jewelry, something he wouldn't necessarily buy for himself, can become an incredibly meaningful gift.

This is another area where independent jewelers have a real advantage over online retailers.

We have conversations. We ask questions. We make recommendations based on the client sitting in front of us. Sometimes a customer doesn't walk into the store looking for a signet ring or a lapel pin. They fall in love with one because someone took the time to show them how it fits their style. That's something an online search simply can't replicate.

I'm certainly not suggesting every independent jeweler suddenly create a large men's jewelry department. That's not the point.

The opportunity is simply to start looking at the category through a different lens.

As consumer tastes evolve, our showcases, and perhaps even our thinking need to evolve with them. When one segment is growing faster than the industry as a whole, I think it's worth asking a simple question: Are our showcases keeping pace?

¹ Polaris Market Research. Men's Jewelry Market Size, Share, Trends & Industry Analysis Report (2025–2034).
https://www.polarismarketresearch.com/industry-analysis/mens-jewelry-market

² Financial Times. Jewellery is becoming increasingly genderless.
https://www.ft.com/content/dfdcf758-e204-48e9-9647-92599db4826f

³ Financial Times. The return of the brooch: why men are pinning again (reporting includes Sotheby's data on male brooch collectors).
https://www.ft.com/content/08976781-218e-4f0c-a43c-8f37490cffb9

Sherry Smith is a principal partner at The Retail Smiths, a consultancy for retailers and vendors and a recognized authority in jewelry retail strategy, with more than three decades of industry experience. Having owned and operated stores, built high-performing teams and navigated both growth and contraction cycles, Smith brings a combination of real-world execution and strategic insight. Her work centers on helping independent jewelers strengthen profitability through financial clarity, disciplined inventory management and leadership accountability. She can be reached at theretailsmiths@gmail.com.