The Retail Smiths: There’s More Than One Way to Win in Watches

Canton, MA--I've always believed the best business decisions are made when experience and good data point in the same direction. The deeper I dug into the watch category, the more the numbers confirmed something many retailers have been feeling for years.

The watch business isn’t simply changing. It’s becoming increasingly polarized.

At the top of the market, the numbers are remarkable. According to the Federation of the Swiss Watch Industry (FH), the United States is now the largest market for Swiss watches, accounting for approximately 17% of all Swiss watch exports. Statista Consumer Market Insights projects the U.S. luxury watch market will exceed $11 billion in 2026, making it one of the largest luxury watch markets in the world.

A relatively small group of brands continues to dominate that business. Morgan Stanley and LuxeConsult estimate that Rolex alone represents nearly one-third of the luxury watch market by retail value. Add Cartier, Patek Philippe, Audemars Piguet and Omega, and more than half of the industry's retail value is concentrated among just a handful of brands.

But that's only half the story.

One of the most fascinating statistics I came across was this: according to the Federation of the Swiss Watch Industry, watches exported at wholesale values above approximately $3,700 account for only about 13% of Swiss watch units, yet they generate nearly 80% of the industry's export value. Conversely, watches exported below approximately $250 represent well over half of all units shipped but account for only a small percentage of the dollars.

In other words, the luxury watch business wins on value, while much of the rest of the industry continues to win on volume.

That's encouraging news for many independent jewelers.

Not every store has—or needs—Rolex, Cartier or Patek Philippe to build a successful watch business. Brands such as Citizen, Seiko, Bulova, Tissot, Hamilton and Longines continue to introduce new customers to the category, generate meaningful unit sales, and create opportunities around gifting, milestone celebrations and self-purchase. In fact, INSTORE Magazine’s 2025 Big Survey identified Citizen as the top-earning watch line among independent jewelers, with nearly twice as many mentions as Rolex. Seiko ranked third, reinforcing that there is still significant opportunity for retailers outside the ultra-luxury segment.

The opportunity, then, isn’t necessarily to become a luxury watch destination.

For retailers who choose to be in the watch business, the opportunity is to understand their customer and intentionally build a watch strategy that reflects their market.

For the relatively small number of retailers representing the industry's elite brands, that may mean cultivating collectors, hosting exclusive events and managing limited allocations. For many others, however, those opportunities simply aren't available. Luxury watch brands tightly control their distribution, making it difficult—even impossible—for many independent jewelers to gain access to the industry's most coveted names.

That’s one reason I believe Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) deserves so much attention.

Unlike authorized luxury brand distribution, which is tightly controlled, the growth of CPO has created a meaningful avenue for many independent jewelers to participate in the luxury watch market. As consumer confidence in authenticated pre-owned watches continues to grow, retailers can attract collectors, facilitate trade-ins and upgrades, and offer customers access to prestigious brands that may otherwise be unavailable. It also creates an opportunity to build recurring relationships with clients who appreciate exceptional timepieces but may not have access to—or interest in—the new luxury market.

For other retailers, success may look different still. It may mean becoming the trusted destination for thoughtfully curated brands that resonate with their customer base. Watches remain a powerful category for gifting, self-purchase and milestone celebrations. For many consumers, brands like Citizen and Seiko represent the beginning of a lifelong appreciation for watches. They often serve as the first step in a collecting journey that may eventually lead to luxury brands.

Perhaps that's the biggest takeaway from all this data.

The watch business isn't becoming smaller; it's becoming more defined.

For some independent jewelers, that means building a destination around prestige luxury brands. For others, it means leveraging the growing opportunities within Certified Pre-Owned. And for many, it means curating an assortment of quality brands that align with their customer, their market and their business strategy.

The right approach is the one that best aligns with your customer, your market and your long-term business strategy.

The retailers who will thrive won't be the ones trying to be everything to everyone. They'll be the ones who understand their customer, define their position and execute it exceptionally well.

Sherry Smith is a principal partner at The Retail Smiths, a consultancy for retailers and vendors and a recognized authority in jewelry retail strategy, with more than three decades of industry experience. Having owned and operated stores, built high-performing teams and navigated both growth and contraction cycles, Smith brings a combination of real-world execution and strategic insight. Her work centers on helping independent jewelers strengthen profitability through financial clarity, disciplined inventory management and leadership accountability. She can be reached at theretailsmiths@gmail.com.